September sales were up in all but two
categories on a monthly basis and up across the board year-over-year, led by
increases at clothing, electronics, and general merchandise stores.
Clothing and clothing accessory stores were up 1.1%
month-over-month seasonally adjusted and up 22.5% unadjusted year-over-year.
Sporting goods stores, meanwhile, were up 3.7%
month-over-month seasonally adjusted and up 13% unadjusted year-over-year.
Greater emphasis on apparel
Neil Saunders, managing director of GlobalData, notes
although many commentators are jittery about the trajectory of the economy,
consumers dismissed those concerns in September as they continued their retail
spending spree.
He says: “Total spend rose by 14.3% over the prior
year and was up by 22% over the same period in 2019. In monetary terms, this
equates to consumers spending $75.8bn more than they did in 2020 and $110.7bn
more than they did two years ago. The outcome is especially pleasing because
September of last year was a reasonably robust month for retail, which meant the
sector was lapping a tough comparative.”
Saunders adds a lot of gains continue to come
from a diversion of spend from services to spending on products.
“Consumers continue to travel, commute, and vacation
less than they did pre-pandemic and the expenditure that would normally be made
on these activities has found a new home in retail. Notably, the allocation of
spending has changed over the course of the pandemic. Early on, the focus was
on upgrading homes and while this is still the case, now a greater emphasis is
being placed on personal indulgences in the form of apparel, beauty, and
accessories. This is aided by the fact people are socialising and leaving their
homes more than they did last year.
“The trends show up in the category
numbers, with apparel stores growing by 22.5% – the best rate of growth of any
core retail sector this month. Admittedly, inflation has played a role here as
the levels of discounting and promotions are well down on last year and years
that have gone before, but volumes are also healthy as consumers treat
themselves to new garments for the fall and winter season. Department stores,
which generally have a high proportion of their sales mix in apparel, are also
seeing gains, with sales for the segment up by 21.4% over 2020.”
However, for all the good news, Saunders notes the
numbers point to some slight notes of caution.
“The first of these is the trend of
slowing growth which is now very apparent. While September growth was solid, it
was the lowest since March. This shows that the elevated momentum will not
continue indefinitely and that, over the medium term, growth will continue to
trend down until it reaches more normalised levels. There might be some
variation during the final months of the year if consumers decide to go on a
big spending spree to celebrate the holidays, but this will be the exception
rather than the rule.
“The second worrying sign is that some
big-ticket purchases like automotive have softened significantly. Here it is
difficult to dissect the impact of product shortages from that of consumers
being less confident to spend large amounts of money, but the latter is
certainly playing something of a role.
“The third trend to watch is inflation.
This is not yet at a level where it is dissuading consumers from buying, but a
cold winter, along with very elevated prices for electricity and heating oil
and gas could erode consumer spending power.
“As retail heads for a strong end to the
year, all these things are tomorrow’s problems. But they could well bring
retail down to earth with a bump in 2022.” By Just Style