US apparel shipments from all sources sank in October
as consumer demand continued to wane with Bangladesh bearing the brunt after
wage protests in the country and a sluggish economy.
US apparel imports fell 8.3% in October to 2bn SME with shipments from six of the ten biggest suppliers showing a decline according to the latest data from the US Office of Textiles and Apparel.
The biggest decline in shipments to the US
came from Bangladesh during October at a staggering 30% drop in volumes,
marking the third consecutive month it has experienced its worst performance in
apparel exports.
This was followed by Honduras and Mexico
which both booked shipment declines of 19%. Interestingly, Mexico slid right
down to the bottom of the table of top 10 apparel suppliers to the US, having
previously sat in front of Honduras, Pakistan and Nicaragua.
In a turn of events China saw a surge in
shipment volumes by 10%, as did Pakistan which enjoyed shipment volume growth
of 12%
“US apparel imports fell to a new low in
October 2023, reflecting consumers’ weakened demand and lack of confidence in
their household’s short-term financial outlook,” observes Dr Sheng Lu,
associate professor in the Department of Fashion and Apparel Studies at the
University of Delaware. “Specifically, US apparel imports in October 2023 were
8.3% lower in quantity and 21.9% lower in value from a year ago. However, after
removing the seasonal factor, apparel imports in October 2023 were nearly 7%
lower in value and quantity compared to September, the worst performance in the
most recent six months.
The US’ largest supplier of apparel, China,
booked shipment volumes of 755bn SME, down 21% from 961bn SME for the same
period a year earlier.
Vietnam, the second largest apparel exporter
to the US of the top 10 major shippers also saw shipment volumes decline to
325bn SME from 435bn SME a year earlier, which is a drop of 25%.
Bangladesh shipment volumes fell 29.5% from
276bn SME to 195bn SME while India’s declined from 133bn SME to 105bn SME.
Indonesia booked a decline in volumes from
123bn SME to 88bn SME while Pakistan’s exports to the US fell from 78m SME to
57m SME.
Honduras and Nicaragua’s exports to the US
fell also to 58bn SME and 50bn SME respectively, from earlier exports of 78bn
SME and 56bn SME.
Mexico, saw shipment volumes decline to 59bn
SME from 67bn SME.
Lu explains several macroeconomic indicators
reveal a tepid market sentiment. For example, the latest consumer confidence
index stood at 70.0 (Jan 2019=100) in October 2023, a straight three months of
decline from 78.4 in July. Likewise, the retail sales index of US clothing
stores also fell from 121 (January 2019=100) in January 2023 to 118 in October.
As November to February is typically the off-season for apparel sourcing, it
remains to be seen when the US apparel import volume will pick up again.
Lu notes that Mexico has been one of the
leading sources of US apparel imports in the Western Hemisphere for decades.
However, due to the growing competition with Asian products, Mexico’s market
share has been constantly declining from 5% in 2010 to 3.2% in 2022 (in value).
“In the first ten months of 2023, we see
Mexico’s market share slightly rise to 3.6%, reflecting US fashion companies’
growing interest in exploring near-shoring opportunities in the Western
Hemisphere. However, industry sources also indicate that importing apparel from
Mexico by taking advantage of the de minimis rules has become more popular.
Thus, the patterns of US apparel imports from Mexico deserve more scrutiny.”
Meanwhile, Bangladesh has experienced the
worst performance in its apparel exports to the US market for three consecutive
months among the top ten suppliers.
Lu notes, specifically in October 2023, US
apparel imports from Bangladesh sharply fell by 30.9% in quantity and 36.5% in
value, far worse than the world average (down 8.3% in quantity and 21.9% in
value).
“However, the result does not necessarily
mean that US fashion companies suddenly lose interest in sourcing from
Bangladesh; instead, it reflects the disproportional negative impact of
weakened US import demand on countries like Bangladesh that primarily provide
large-volume basic apparel items. In comparison, as US fashion companies switch
to place small-volume sourcing orders in the current business environment,
those countries that can offer greater sourcing flexibility and agility tend to
perform better.”
During October Bangladesh saw violent
protests erupt over worker pay in factories after
industry bodies warned the increased worker wages would pressure factories into
holding back on sustainable measures.
The uproar sparked fear across the country’s
apparel sector that fashion buyers might reduce orders from the
country.
This coincided with news the Bangladesh
Garment Exporters Association had called on the International Monetary Fund to
support the development of Bangladesh’s ready-made garment sector, given its
pivotal role in the country’s economy.
Since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022,
Bangladesh’s dollar reserves have fallen by more than a third, according to Reuters and
the country had previously secured a loan of $4.7bn from the IMF.
Lu points out the latest trade data reveals
the direct impact of political stability on a country’s attractiveness as an
apparel sourcing base for US fashion companies.
“Notably, countries with a stable political
and business environment performed far better than those suffering from
domestic violence and chaos in the same region.
“For example, in the first ten months of
2023, US apparel imports from several members of the African Growth and
Opportunity Act (AGOA), including Kenya and Madagascar, outperformed the market
average. However, after losing the AGOA benefits, Ethiopia’s apparel exports to
the US have sharply declined by nearly 40% so far in 2023, followed by Lesotho
(down 35%).
“Likewise, among CAFTA-DR members, US
apparel imports from Nicaragua (down 30%) were much worse than those from the
Dominican Republic (up 38%) and El Salvador (down 18%). As geopolitics becomes
a more significant concern to businesses of all kinds, factors such as
political stability, trade policies, and international relations will grow in
importance in fashion companies’ sourcing decisions.”
By Just Style