Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia hold significant potential
as sourcing bases for clothing made from recycled cotton for Western fashion
companies, but there are a number of advancements that will need to be made to
make it viable on a larger-scale.
A
new study has shed light on the potential of Egypt, Morocco and Tunisia as
sourcing bases for clothing made from recycled cotton.
Consumers’ growing demand for sustainable
apparel products means fashion companies are increasingly carrying clothing
made from recycled textile materials and seeking additional supply bases.
Recycled cotton has great potential for use in garments because of the wide
availability of cotton-made second-hand clothing and the perceived positive
environmental impacts of effectively recycling post-consumption cotton waste.
Asia plays a dominant role as the world’s
largest exporter of regular clothing made of virgin fibre, however it may not
necessarily be the case for clothing made from recycled cotton, given the
unique supply chain composition of such products.
In fact, due to the growing concern about
forced labour risks involved in the Asia-based cotton apparel supply chain,
fashion companies are eager to diversify their sourcing of cotton apparel in
other world regions. Such a pattern also applies to clothing using recycled
cotton fibre.
Notably, North African countries, including
Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia, have a long history of making and exporting cotton
and cotton-made finished garments. The “developing country” status and
membership in trade agreements or trade preference programmes, such as the
African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) and the EU-Mediterranean Association
Agreement, allow apparel products from these three countries to enjoy
preferential duty benefits in the world’s top import markets. The cotton
apparel industry has also played a critical role in driving local economic
growth in these three countries. Therefore, it is essential to capitalise on
recycled cotton apparel and “green exports” to promote economic development in
the region further.
From January 2022 to April 2024, Inditex-owned fashion brand Zara appeared to be the single largest retailer that
carried clothing using recycled cotton from Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia.
Several other well-known brands or retailers, many targeting the value and mass market segments, also sell such products,
including Calvin Klein (US), Tommy Hilfiger (US), Mud Jeans (Netherlands), and
Spartoo (France). However, it remains relatively less prevalent for smaller to
medium-sized companies and those primarily targeting the luxury or premium
market segments to carry recycled cotton apparel from these three countries.
Of the collected samples, apparel using
recycled cotton from Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia was destined for as many as 49 countries, reflecting the global demand for such products. However, possibly
restrained by the limited supply, the export market for clothing using recycled
cotton remained less diverse than that for clothing made of regular cotton,
which spanned 72 countries.
Geographically, the European Union (EU) was the top
clothing export market for Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia, accounting for over 75%
of these countries’ export value in 2022, according to UN trade statistics
(UNComtrade).
This was also the case for recycled cotton products. Specifically, the EU accounted for 65% of these three countries’ total recycled cotton clothing exports measured in Stock Keeping Units (SKUs) in the collected samples, higher than 59.4% of regular cotton clothing products. The results could be attributed to the unique supply chain and process of making clothing using recycled cotton, making producers in Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia more inclined to partner with the EU in production and sales. Additionally, focusing on the EU market may offer Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia producers more advantages in promoting the concept of “local or local” and controlling the costs of collecting, sorting, shipping, and processing textile waste, compared to other more geographically distant markets like the United States and Asia.
The results suggest that Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia focused on different product categories for clothing using recycled cotton than those made from regular cotton. Specifically, of the sampled items, clothing using recycled cotton had a notable concentration on bottoms (52.9%), followed by tops other than T-shirts (23.8%). Recycled cotton clothing also was more commonly used for outerwear (7.5%) than those using regular cotton (3.8%). In comparison, only about 7.9% of clothing using recycled cotton were T-shirts, much fewer than nearly 30% of those using regular cotton. Similarly, specific product categories, such as underwear and hosiery, rarely use recycled cotton. Likely, the concerns for quality and durability and the difficulty of absorbing higher production costs make using recycled cotton for these relatively simple categories more challenging.Even though cotton apparel made in Egypt,
Morocco, and Tunisia already commonly mentioned their sustainability attributes
(86%), phrases such as
“sustainability” and “sustainable” appeared even more
frequently in clothing using recycled cotton (94.6%). For example, some producers highlighted that
they “worked with suppliers, workers, unions and international organisations”
to ensure their recycled cotton clothing contributed to “the United Nations
Sustainable Development Goals.” Likewise, some labels intentionally remind
consumers about the positive environmental impact of using recycled cotton:
“The use of recycled cotton helps to limit the consumption of raw materials.”
Another added: “The production of recycled cotton recovered cotton, mainly from
the production of other garments, thus reducing the production of virgin spring
and water consumption, energy and natural resources.”
Meanwhile, compared to clothing using
regular cotton, those made with recycled cotton in Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia
reported much higher participation in certification
programmes, such as the Recycled Claim Standard (RCS), which
verifies the recycled content and tracks it from source to final product.
Notably, a growing number of legislation has been newly adopted in the EU and
the US, requiring apparel products containing recycled content to prove the
fibre claims. Thus, with the growing call for transparency and accountability
in sustainability claims, participating in a certification programme may soon
become obligatory for producers asserting the use of recycled cotton fibre in
their clothing.
However, reflecting the technical
limitations of the fibre property, it
remains rare to have clothing that is 100% made from recycled cotton.
According to industry experts, longer cotton fibres generally indicate higher
quality. Since the recycling process shortens cotton fibres, regular virgin
cotton or other fibres like polyester are typically used alongside recycled
cotton to make fabrics smoother, stronger, and more durable. For example,
common labels include descriptions such as “80% virgin cotton, 20% RCS
certified recycled cotton” and “55% RCS certified recycled polyester, 45% RCS
certified recycled cotton.”
However, the results show that except for
T-shirts, in most cases, clothing made from recycled cotton in Egypt, Morocco,
and Tunisia was priced lower
than their equivalent using virgin fibre in the market. This is particularly
the case for the premium and luxury
market segments, where clothing using recycled fibre typically
was 20-30% lower priced than regular clothing. The results echo the findings of
numerous studies indicating that consumers are generally unwilling to pay
higher prices for recycled fibre clothing as they perceive such products as
lower quality and less “valuable.” The results also reveal the business
challenges, such as the lack of financial incentives, for producers in Egypt,
Morocco, and Tunisia to expand the production scale and increase the use of
recycled cotton in their products.
The study demonstrates the significant
potential of Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia as sourcing bases for clothing made
from recycled cotton for Western fashion companies. More efforts could be made
to advance techniques to improve the quality of recycled cotton fibre,
diversify its use in product categories, reduce production costs, and further
increase the added value of clothing using recycled fibre. Additionally,
exploring policy support to provide financial incentives for producing,
trading, and consuming recycled cotton garments, as opposed to those made from
virgin fibres, could further enhance the viability and appeal of recycled
cotton in the global fashion market.
By Just Style