Trump's presidential win has been met with mixed
feelings in the US apparel, footwear and retail sectors which welcome plans for
a tax cut but are concerned by proposed tariff hikes.
As the US and much of the world gears up for life under newly elected President Donald Trump, the US apparel, footwear and retail sectors consider what changes they can expect to see and what it will mean for the way they do business.
For US retail an anticipated tax cut will be
welcomed, but there is significant concern around looming tariffs under Trump
which could further pressure consumer spending in an already constrained
environment.
Trump
has floated a wide range of proposals to impose new tariffs on imports into the
United States. Two specific proposals call for greater scrutiny: A) a
universal tariff of 10% or even 20% on all imports into the United States from
all countries, and B) an additional tariff of 60% or even 100% on all imports
from China on top of existing tariffs.
Shore Capital analyst Clive Black notes it
was a “clear win” for Trump and one that has the basis to “notably change the
course of US policy in many areas”.
“Amid the initial digestion, the new
President takes office in February, and so there is time for dust to settle and
to further gauge where his policy priorities will be set.”
But Black notes his policies could impact
other global markets albeit in an indirect manner and particularly concerning
plans around tariffs.
“A quite upfront policy arena for Trump in
his election campaign, where he has demonstrably scored many more positive
punches with the electorate on economic matters than his opponent, is tariffs.
Whether the UK food and non-food sectors are at the forefront of his new
Government’s attention on such matters, is doubtful over exports from say
China, Brazil and India, and maybe France too. However, the waves from tariffs
can lap into domestic markets in many ways.
“Additionally, tariffs tend to work in two
ways and what response may China impose on US exports if high tariffs on its
goods are applied, and how does this work through into wider trade flows and
the global economy?
“It is a major potential headache for global
economic trade and growth. Additionally, within the US there is the matter of
what high import tariffs on material product categories may mean for US
consumer prices, food and ‘gas’ inflation were notable points of resonance for
Trump in the election with voters, and how would any evolving tariff infused
consumer price environment work through for US Fed rates?”
And Black also raises concerns around
geopolitical tensions with Trump coming in amid the Russia-Ukraine and
Gaza-Israel-Lebanon conflicts, and now Iran. He says the former “has already
had notable implications upon the UK consumer economy.”
He adds: “Current times embrace big
geopolitical risk,” but that said, he believes “conditioning factors that can
be expected to evolve with the consequential outcomes to follow will come
through as Mr Trump takes office.”
GlobalData retail analyst Neil Saunders said
not for the first time in his life, Trump has “stunned the nation and the
world”.
But his return to power means many of his
policies, that people thought they had seen the back of, will come back into
play.
For US retail, one of the biggest positives,
he says, is that Trump will almost certainly renew the tax cut package he
introduced during his first term in 2017, which was due to expire at the end of
2025.
“This will be broadly helpful to consumer
incomes, although retailers should not expect to see a surge in spending as it
is about rolling over an existing policy that is already baked into consumer
behaviour.”
He adds there is a possibility general taxes
might be cut further, facilitated “by a friendly congress” though a soaring
budget deficit will inevitably act as a constraint here.
“As such, it’s likely that new cuts will be
targeted and focused on exempting tips and overtime pay from income tax and
allowing households to take more deductions. In the round, this will put more
money into consumers’ pockets and will bring a small boost to retail spending.”
Trump’s proposed corporation tax cut of 15%
will likely further benefit retail earnings and facilitate US retail
investment.
On the other hand, the biggest downside to
the US retail sector will be Trump’s proposals around tariffs.
“While immediate action is unlikely as any
new tariffs would take time to implement, the threat of increasing tariffs on
China to 60% and on other countries to 10% to 20% would create a major headache
and add significant additional cost for retail. Despite Trump’s assertions to
the contrary, tariffs are paid by the companies or entities importing goods and
not by the countries themselves. This means the cost of buying products from
overseas, whether directly or as an input for manufacturing, would rise sharply.
“Given the trade between Chinese
manufacturers and US retailers, a strict tariff policy would mean retailers
initially either taking a big hit on profits or being forced to put up prices,
which would fuel inflation and dampen retail volumes. Over time, supply chains
would adjust to a new tariff regime, but this would not happen overnight. The
small hope is that the tough talk on tariffs is more of a negotiating ploy, and
that a serious policy play and that what is finally implemented will be
relatively modest in scope.
“A side effect of tariffs and higher prices
would be interest rates staying higher for longer, which would be unhelpful for
the housing market which, in turn, will act as a drag on home-related
categories. While Trump promised lower interest rates, and wants more control
over the setting of rates, it is not in his immediate gift to enact this kind
of change.”
The initial response to the election results
is mixed, asserts Julie Hughes, president of the US Fashion Industry
Association.
Many fashion brands and retailers anticipate
a positive tax environment with Trump as President and a Republican-controlled
Senate. Still, equally, there is a lot of anxiety about the economic outlook,
she notes “especially with Trump talking about his love for tariffs”.
“Higher tariffs would spike prices and
increase inflation. And the uncertainty about trade policy and higher tariffs
will make it harder to plan for 2025 and beyond. We will be talking about the
outlook and options at our conference next week as the experts assess the
impact on the fashion industry.”
The AAFA’s president and CEO Steve Lamar
says tariff policy under the new administration will trigger new inflationary
cycles if campaign proposals are fully enacted, making it more expensive for
Americans to get dressed every day.
“We have seen first-hand the negative impact
of tariffs ever since the tariffs imposed under the Tariff Act of 1930 helped
create the Great Depression. The Section 301 tariffs that took hold in 2018
under President Trump’s first term have also remained in place, driving 40-year
high inflation for clothes and shoes. Tariffs are taxes paid by U.S.-based
businesses and American consumers, not on China or other supplier countries.
These tariffs disproportionately harm lower-income American consumers and female
consumers with higher tariffs on lower priced products and on women’s clothes
and shoes.”
But the AAFA is pinning its hopes on working
with Congress and the Administration to renew expired and expiring trade
programmes including The African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), the
Generalized System of Preferences (GSP), and the Haiti HELP/HOPE preference
programme.
“Immediate and long-term renewal of these
measures, combined with a revived trade agreement program, will create
predictable opportunities for our industry to diversify and invest, creating
American jobs and supporting the provision of affordable and sustainable
fashion for American families. We also look forward to initiatives to protect
our shipping channels and ports put a stop to the influx of counterfeit goods
across third-party e-commerce platforms, and drive other policies that are not
just well-meaning but well-crafted, implementable, practical, harmonized, and
ultimately – successful.
“Beyond Washington, our work will continue
with elected officials in state capitols around the country, making sure that
state regulations are harmonized and effective, and incorporate stakeholder
input.”
National Retail Federation president and CEO
Matthew Shay said effective trade policies will increase America’s competitive
advantages in research, development and innovation and will protect
strategically critical infrastructure while increasing the standard of living
and quality of life for all Americans.
“However, the adoption of across-the-board
tariffs on consumer goods and other non-strategic imports amounts to a tax on
American families. It will drive inflation and price increases and will result
in job losses,” Shay warned.
“The retail industry stands ready to work
with President-elect Trump and Congress to enact tax, trade and regulatory
policies that make America more competitive, increase domestic investment and
create jobs.”
By Just Style